
Gas vs Electric Water Heaters in Lehi, Utah
Choosing a fuel for a new water heater in Lehi, or thinking of switching? See what each one needs here, then call or text and ask for the price on your house.
- Enbridge gas or city power
- Utah's gas rule, in plain words
- What a fuel switch involves
Water heater trouble?
- Gas utility
- Enbridge Gas Utah, where natural gas is available
- Electric
- Lehi City Power, with Rocky Mountain Power also in the area
- Gas leak line
- 800-767-1689
- Rebates
- ThermWise lists amounts for gas units
The cheapest fuel for a Lehi water heater is usually the one the house already has. Gas tends to cost less to run and recovers faster, but it needs a gas line, a vent and, in Lehi, a model that meets Utah's ultra-low-nitrogen oxides (NOx) rule. Electric is simpler to place and vent, and it needs a strong dedicated circuit. Call or text, tell us what you have now, and you'll get a call right back with a price for your choice before any work starts.
Gas or electric: which one do you have now?
Check three things, and you will know in a minute.
- A metal flue on top: a gas water heater vents combustion gases up and out.
- A gas line and a dial: a gas heater has a shutoff valve on a pipe and a control with a temperature dial near the base.
- Electrical conduit: an electric heater has wires entering the side or top, and no flue.
Say which you have when you call. Matching the existing fuel avoids new piping, venting or wiring, which is why it is usually the lowest price.
How do gas and electric heaters compare?
Each has strengths, and the table puts them side by side.
| Gas | Electric | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront price | usually higher, with venting | usually lower |
| Running cost | often lower, depends on rates | often higher, depends on rates |
| Recovery speed | fast | slower |
| Install needs | gas line, flue | heavy dedicated circuit |
| Utah's NOx rule | applies to new units | does not apply |
Neither wins everywhere. Gas recovers faster, which suits a household that showers in a rush each morning. Electric fits homes with no gas, an addition or a spot where a flue can't run, and a heat pump model cuts its running cost.

Who supplies each fuel in Lehi?
Enbridge Gas Utah serves Lehi, formerly under the Dominion Energy Utah and Questar Gas names, and you may still see those on old paperwork. Lehi's own utilities page names Enbridge as the gas provider. Coverage by street isn't published, so look for a gas meter and a gas line at your house before planning a gas heater.
Electric service comes from Lehi City Power, the city's own utility, and Rocky Mountain Power also has a service-area agreement with Lehi. The boundary isn't published street by street, so your bill is the only reliable answer.
What do Utah's rules add to a gas heater?
Utah's rules reach a new gas water heater here in ways that surprise people.
- Ultra-low-NOx: Lehi is in the area where Utah bans selling or installing gas water heaters above its NOx limit, up to 75,000 BTU/hr. Units made before July 1, 2018 and other fuels are exempt, so an existing heater can stay, but a new gas one must comply. See the state's page (opens in a new tab).
- Altitude: at about 4,500 feet, what a gas burner needs depends on the model. Bradford White builds for sea level to 2,000 feet and says to contact it above that; A.O. Smith's Signature 100 residential series is approved to 7,700 feet.
- Strapping: earthquake straps are required on every water heater, gas or electric.
Weighing a fuel switch? Call or text and ask what your house would need.
What does switching fuels involve?
A switch is possible either way, and it is permitted work under Utah's construction code.
- Electric to gas: gas must reach the house first. Then the job adds a gas line to the heater, a vent route to the outside and a compliant ultra-low-NOx model.
- Gas to electric: the old gas line is capped and the flue retired, and the panel needs room for a dedicated circuit sized to the heater.
- Gas to a heat pump: the same circuit question, plus space, airflow and usually a condensate drain.
Ask that the quote lists the piping, vent or circuit as its own line, so you can see what the switch adds over a like-for-like swap.
What help is there with the cost?
Enbridge Gas Utah's ThermWise rebates (opens in a new tab) currently list $100 for an ENERGY STAR gas storage heater, $300 for gas tankless and $350 for gas condensing storage. Mail the claim, with a postmark, inside 6 months of installation.
Lehi City Power's rebate page points electric water heaters to a Utah Associated Municipal Power Systems program with no listed dollar amount, so call before you buy.
What if the heater has simply stopped working?
Then the fuel decision can wait. A gas heater that won't light and an electric heater that won't heat are usually one failed part, and the water heater repair page covers them. If you smell gas, leave the house, then from a safe place call 911 and Enbridge's leak line at 800-767-1689. Enbridge's leak page (opens in a new tab) says not to operate gas valves during an emergency.
Choosing a fuel across Lehi
Requests are covered from the blocks near Historic Main Street to the newer streets of Traverse Mountain and Holbrook Farms, plus Bluffdale's 84065. Tank size is the other half of the choice, and the sizing guide covers it.
Not sure which fuel suits the house? Describe the current heater by call or text.
Questions homeowners ask
How do I know if my water heater is gas or electric?
A gas heater has a flue pipe rising from the top, a gas line with a shutoff valve and a control dial near the bottom. An electric heater has a metal conduit with wires entering a panel on the side or top and no flue.
Who supplies natural gas in Lehi?
Enbridge Gas Utah, which Lehi's own utilities page names as the gas provider. Natural gas is not on every street, so check whether your address has a gas line.
Who supplies electricity for an electric water heater in Lehi?
Lehi has its own city-run electric utility, Lehi City Power, and Rocky Mountain Power also holds a service-area agreement with the city. Your bill shows which one serves you.
Is gas or electric cheaper to run in Lehi?
It depends on your own rates, and no single winner is published for Lehi. A gas heater often costs less to run but more to vent and install, so compare your Enbridge and electric bills.
Can I switch my Lehi water heater from electric to gas?
Where natural gas reaches the house, yes, but it adds a gas line, a vent and an ultra-low-NOx model. Going the other way may need a new circuit. Either change is permitted work.
Are there rebates for gas or electric water heaters in Lehi?
Enbridge's ThermWise program currently lists $100 for an ENERGY STAR gas storage heater and $300 for gas tankless. Electric heaters point to a Utah municipal power program that lists no dollar amount.
Last updated: